I went in and defeated the Tomb Wretch Claviger in the tomb of Queassam the Great. I had a crystalline shard with me and got the message "Frohste has successfully captured a creature!" So I headed down to the statue of Ben to turn in my shard and got this message: "Frohste tries and fails to complete part of a quest!" And POOF! The shard I just paid so much plat for was gone!
Resolved.
- J.